Mild Cigars for Beginners

A first cigar should be easy to enjoy. Mild cigars burn cool, taste smooth and let you find the flavors you like, such as cream, cedar, nuts and a little sweetness, without the pepper and weight of a full-bodied smoke.

Strength is about how heavy a cigar feels, not how good it is. Plenty of long-time smokers reach for a mild cigar in the morning or with coffee.

What makes a cigar mild

Most of it is the leaf. Shade-grown wrappers, Connecticut Shade above all, are thin, light in color and gentle in flavor. Fillers from the Dominican Republic tend to be mellower than the same style grown in Nicaragua.

Size matters a little too. A thicker cigar burns cooler and slower, so a robusto or toro is a more forgiving first smoke than a thin, quick-burning one.

How to pick your first

Buy two or three different singles, not a box. Smoke them slowly, about one puff a minute, on a full stomach and with something to drink. Note the ones you'd smoke again, then try another size of the same line.

Mild cigars in stock

Compare them

CigarStrengthWrapperSizeSmoking timeSingle
Espinosa Crema Box Pressed ToroMellow-mediumEcuador Connecticut6 x 521 hour to 1 hour 20 minutes$16.00
Oscar Valladares Leaf by Oscar Connecticut ToroMellow-mediumHonduras Connecticut6 x 521 hour to 1 hour 20 minutes$15.00
Davidoff Primeros Dominican Petit PanetelaMellow-mediumEcuador4.125 x 3425 to 35 minutes$8.50
Oscar Valladares Heaven & Hell Claro ToroMellowHonduras Connecticut6 x 521 hour to 1 hour 20 minutes$14.50
Espinosa Sumatra ToroMellow-mediumEcuador Sumatra6 x 541 hour 5 minutes to 1 hour 25 minutes$14.50
Plasencia Reserva Original CortezMellow-mediumNicaragua5.75 x 561 hour to 1 hour 20 minutes$15.50
Ashton Classic MajestyMellowConnecticut Shade6 x 561 hour 5 minutes to 1 hour 25 minutes$22.00
Cohiba Connecticut ToroMellow-mediumEcuador Connecticut6.5 x 521 hour 10 minutes to 1 hour 30 minutes$33.00
The Griffin's Classic ToroMellow-mediumEcuador Connecticut6.25 x 521 hour 5 minutes to 1 hour 25 minutes$21.50
Plasencia Reserva Original RobustoMellow-mediumNicaragua4.75 x 5245 minutes to 1 hour$13.50
Ashton Cabinet Selection BelicosoMellow-mediumConnecticut Shade5.25 x 5250 minutes to 1 hour 5 minutes$19.50
Ashton Cabinet Selection No. 7Mellow-mediumConnecticut Shade6.25 x 521 hour 5 minutes to 1 hour 25 minutes$21.00

More cigar guides · Brands A–Z