Straight Cut vs V-Cut vs Punch
All three open the closed end of the cigar so air can pass. They differ in how much they open.
Straight cut
A straight, or guillotine, cut slices the cap off flat. It gives the most open draw and works on every shape and size. Cut just above where the cap meets the body, never below it, or the wrapper can unravel. A double-blade cutter cuts cleaner than a single blade.
V-cut
A V-cut takes a wedge out of the cap and leaves the edges. The draw is a little tighter and the smoke more concentrated on the tongue. It keeps loose tobacco out of your mouth, and it suits cigars with a wide ring gauge.
Punch
A punch removes a small round plug. It leaves the most cap, so it is the tidiest in the mouth, but it can run tight on a long cigar. It does not work on pointed heads such as a torpedo or belicoso.
The three cuts at a glance
| Straight | V-cut | Punch | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Opens | The whole cap | A wedge | A small hole |
| Draw | Most open | Medium | Tightest |
| Works on pointed heads | Yes | Yes | No |
| Good for | Any cigar | Thicker cigars | Smaller ring gauges |
Which cutter should you buy?
If you are buying one, buy a double-blade straight cutter that fits a 60 ring gauge or more. Add a V-cutter later if you smoke larger cigars. Each cutter's page lists the cut type and the ring gauge it fits.
Cigar cutters in the store
Colibri SV-Cut 2 in 1 Black · $89.50 each
S.T. Dupont ST Dupont Double Blade Black · $245.00 each
S.T. Dupont ST Dupont Double Blade Chrome · $245.00 each
S.T. Dupont ST Dupont MaxiJet Cutter Black As Night · $205.00 each
S.T. Dupont ST Dupont MaxiJet Cutter Chrome Grid · $205.00 each
Xikar Revolution Cigar Cutter Black · $140.00 each
Xikar Xi1 Black · $85.00 each
Xikar Xi1 Blue · $85.00 each
Xikar Xi1 Phantom Black/Black Blades · $95.00 each
Xikar Xi1 Silver/Black Blades · $95.00 each
Xikar Xi2 Lapis Blue · $55.00 each
Xikar Xi2 Noir Black · $55.00 each